ChooseBirth Home PageChooseBirth Collection - click here to return to the main page...

{Source:: Culture & Cosmos / April 5, 2004 Volume 1, Number 34. Copyright---Culture of Life Foundation.
Permission granted for unlimited use. Credit required.}

Partial Birth Abortion Judge Quizzes Abortionists about Fetal Pain

Three courts scattered around the country began hearing testimony last week in cases that are testing the constitutionality of the Partial Birth Abortion Ban. Court transcripts show how one Judge’s intense interest in fetal pain has raised hopes among pro-lifers that the ban may be upheld. According to transcripts of opening statements, New York District Court Judge Richard Conway Casey repeatedly questioned abortionists about infant pain during the procedure known as partial birth abortion.

Casey pointedly asked abortion advocate Dr. Timothy Johnson "does the fetus feel pain?" Before allowing Johnson to answer Casey said, "There are studies, I'm told, that says they do." Johnson replied that he had not heard of such studies. Casey asked if the infant's pain "ever crosses your mind when you are doing a dismemberment?" Johnson said no and Casey expressed surprise that fetal pain "never crossed your mind," commenting that "although you have never done (a partial birth abortion), do you know whether or not the incision of the scissors on the base of the skull of the baby, whether that hurts? Did you ever ask one of those who perform them whether it hurts the fetus?"

Casey also wanted to know if the infant was still alive during the procedure and if "the fingers of the baby (were) opening and closing…were the feet moving?" Johnson said that there could be such movement. Casey followed up with a question on the instrument used to remove the baby's head. Johnson described it as tongs such as those used in "picking up salad," but Casey interrupted and said, "Except here you are crushing the head of a baby."

Casey was also concerned with how much information the doctors told the mother about the procedure. He asked, "So you tell her the arms and legs are pulled off. I mean, that's what I want to know, do you tell her…[that] you are going to remove parts of her baby?" Casey returned to the topic later in the examination, "Do you describe in detail what the intact D&E or the partial birth abortion involves…including sucking the brain out of the skull?" Johnson replied that "I don't think we would use those terms…we try to do it in a way that's not offensive or gruesome or overly graphic for patients." Casey asked in response "Can they fully comprehend unless you do?" Casey accused abortionists of making abortion "nice and palatable so that they wouldn't understand what it’s all about."

Dr. Amos Grunebaum testified before Casey about how his clinic attempted to help mothers "as part of the grieving process." During the partial-birth abortion, he said doctors attempt to deliver the baby intact because it "is part of our common policy….that we take pictures" so that "there is a memory of the baby by the mother."

Other abortionists testified about the special difficulty faced when an aborted baby is born moving. Dr. William Fitzhugh, a witness in the Nebraska case, said during direct examination that "the one thing that…I don't want the staff to have to deal with is to have a fetus that you remove and have some viability to it, some movement of limbs, because its always a difficult situation." However, Fitzhugh said that during the partial birth abortions he was aware that "the majority of them are alive at the time."

Dr. William Knorr who also testified in the Nebraska case confirmed, "The majority of the fetuses are alive" during partial-birth abortions. When asked why he didn't "induce fetal demise, as part of your second trimester abortion procedures" before the delivery of the infant, Knorr said, "I just don't believe in it. I think that it's an extra procedure, and you know, we first have to remember, don't do any harm."

Copyright---Culture of Life Foundation.
Permission granted for unlimited use. Credit required.

Culture of Life Foundation
1413 K Street, NW, Suite 1000
Washington DC 20005
Phone: (202) 289-2500
Fax: (202) 289-2502

Top of Page

Email comments, questions, suggestions, errors, new links to: